Nov. 16, 2026

341. Think Outside the Bot: Communicate More Effectively With AI

341. Think Outside the Bot: Communicate More Effectively With AI
341. Think Outside the Bot: Communicate More Effectively With AI
Think Fast Talk Smart
341. Think Outside the Bot: Communicate More Effectively With AI

“If AI is a thought partner, we’ve got to be the thought leader.”

AI can generate ideas, solve problems, and streamline our work. But are we getting the most out of it, or simply settling for the first answer? According to Stanford creativity expert Jeremy Utley, the key is learning to work with AI differently. In this episode of Think Fast, Talk Smart, Utley joins Matt Abrahams to discuss his new book, The Human Advantage: What AI Can't Do Without You. He shares why treating AI as a teammate can unlock better ideas, how asking better questions improves results, and why effective communication is essential to making AI a valuable thinking partner.


Takeaways:

  • Treat AI as a teammate, not just a tool. Providing context, asking better questions, and refining your prompts can lead to more useful and creative results.
  • Better ideas require thinking beyond the obvious. Generating multiple perspectives, including intentionally bad ideas, can spark creativity and prevent us from settling for the first answer.


Activity:

  • Flip the prompt. Next time you use AI to brainstorm, ask it to generate 10 intentionally bad ideas instead of good ones. Look for unexpected perspectives or possibilities you can build on to create something better.

Printable Expanded Takeaways & Activities


Episode Reference Links:

Connect:


Chapters:

  • (00:00) - Introduction
  • (00:51) - AI and Creativity
  • (02:57) - Overcoming Creative Bias
  • (04:49) - AI as a Creative Partner
  • (08:24) - Rethinking Work
  • (11:14) - Embracing AI Assistance
  • (12:29) - Reverse Prompting
  • (14:29) - Communicating With AI
  • (18:37) - The Final Three Questions
  • (22:39) - Conclusion

********
Thank you to our sponsors. These partnerships support the ongoing production of the podcast, allowing us to bring it to you at no cost.

Strawberry.me. Get 50% off your first coaching session today at Strawberry.me/smart

Join our Think Fast Talk Smart Learning Community and become the communicator you want to be.

Chapters

00:00 - Introduction

00:51 - AI and Creativity

02:57 - Overcoming Creative Bias

04:49 - AI as a Creative Partner

08:24 - Rethinking Work

11:14 - Embracing AI Assistance

12:29 - Reverse Prompting

14:29 - Communicating With AI

18:37 - The Final Three Questions

22:39 - Conclusion

Transcript

0:03 When it comes to working with AI and improving our communication, we make a fundamental mistake. AI is not a tool, it's a teammate. My name's Matt Abrahams, and I teach Strategic Communication at Stanford Graduate School of Business. Welcome to Think Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast. Today, I am super excited to chat once again with my Stanford colleague and good friend, Jeremy Utley. Jeremy is a three-time guest to Think Fast, Talk Smart. He's an adjunct professor specializing in creativity and entrepreneurship at Stanford, and the author of Ideaflow. His new book is The Human Advantage: What AI Can't Do Without You. Well, Jeremy, welcome back. I always enjoy our podcast conversations almost as much as I enjoy our walks around the Stanford campus.

0:46 Thanks for being here. Likewise, my friend. Thanks for having me. Yeah. Shall we get started? Let's do it. In your first book, Idea Flow, which is a great book, by the way, you argue that creativity comes from generating lots of ideas. You found that AI-assisted teams can actually become less creative if they just accept AI's first obvious suggestion. How can we prevent AI from becoming an average idea generator and making us intellectually lazy and just relying on whatever we see first? What does it take to have good ideas? So you can start there because the same thing that it takes for a human brain to have good ideas is what it takes for an artificial brain to have good ideas. And by the way, the same biases that prevent humans from having good ideas are what prevent AIs from having good ideas, very simply.

1:31 There's a couple of things worth calling out. One is the reason most of us don't have better ideas is because we won't let ourselves have worse ideas. What you're actually after is variability. You want a variation in the spectrum of ideas. Ideas like all naturally occurring phenomena are normally distributed, right? Some are stupid, some are great, et cetera. The challenge is if you want to get kind of on the far right end of the distribution, you have to be willing to go to the far left end because you can't have an asymmetric distribution. And I was just listening to a podcast with the CEO of Airbnb. He said, "I have 100,000 ideas a year. 99,000 of them are no good." And I think if you ask the lay person to describe the path to having good ideas, they wouldn't say 99% failure rate.

2:18 They just wouldn't do it, right? They think, "I gotta be smart," or, "I gotta go to a good school," or, "I gotta wait for lightning to strike." But they don't think of expanding the variability. What's true for humans is also true for an AI, right? So instead of asking the AI for an idea, one simple lever is ask the AI for 10 ideas, and instead of only using kind of volume as your only lever, ask the AI for 10 radically different ideas. And if you want to get really fun, ask the AI for terrible ideas, right? And your human brain will actually do kind of the fun part of figuring out what's good there. But I think a lot of the problem basically is just thinking about what I need is one good idea. That's actually the problem. So we need to open up our aperture and look for more ideas, and if we're gonna leverage AI, have it help us come up with those more ideas, and sometimes ask it to do the bad ones.

3:08 Absolutely. And then just getting back to another statement that you made earlier, you said, "I found that teams settle." That's true. And the reason that it's true is because of a widely known cognitive bias called satisficing. The fact that we satisfice means we're satisfied by that which suffices, so we satisfice. And so what we do is we kind of settle for good enough, and that's fine. The challenge is that satisficing, while it helps us in the majority of our life get through the otherwise overwhelming amount of information and decisions that we could make, where it kind of nips us in the rear, so to speak, is when we're trying to generate a new idea, right? Or a new product or a new service.

3:49 And so what we know is that this human cognitive bias actually plagues creativity and it plagues innovation. And what Kian, my research partner and I discovered, when we studied teams that we gave access to AI, is the following. Unassisted teams actually worked hard, workshopping, spitballing, going back and forth, devil's advocating, et cetera. Assisted teams often, not always, but often plugged a superficial staccato prompt into an AI, got a pretty mediocre response, and because it's better than the response they could have come up with in that 30 seconds, they declare victory. And they basically satisfice.

4:29 Of course, because they're not grading the ideas, they don't realize what's theoretically possible. They just realize that the AI did something they couldn't have done in that amount of time, and they assume that there's nothing left to do. Which is to say that left without intervention, AI merely amplifies the underlying existing human cognitive bias. So AI actually isn't helping us in that case, it's actually making things worse. You know, you tell lots of great stories, Jeremy, and I always love when you regale me with some of your stories. Would you mind sharing your story about your daughter and the broken window? Yeah. Why I like this story is because most people, when they think about AI, they're thinking about business and efficiency and productivity and that sort of thing.

5:12 And I often say I'm not embarrassed to say that AI has helped me be a better parent. So I tell them the story that I live in a really old house, 130-year-old home, and one of my favorite windows in the house is in the front bathroom of the house. It's got this beautiful glass. And as you know, I've got four girls. And the other morning, I hear a very loud bang in the middle of making breakfast. And then my daughter, she yells. She's like, "Dad, there's glass everywhere. Get up here. Come up here." So I go to the front of the house, and lo and behold, there's glass everywhere. And this beautiful Victorian window that I quite prize and adore is shattered all over the floor. And thankfully, nobody's too hurt, but everybody's looking at me going, "How is Dad gonna respond?" Because basically what had happened, one of the girls needed a little personal space.

5:59 And how did she accomplish that? She decided to slam the door so hard in her sister's face that the window shattered, which is obviously a violation of a few household rules. So the question is, how do I respond? And we all have these broken window moments, and that feeling of, I wish I knew what to do. And so I am not embarrassed to say that AI actually helped me be a better parent to my daughters in that moment. And this is actually part of the core premise of my new book, which is called The Human Advantage. But the basic premise is that the most special thing about AI is actually you, the expertise that you bring to your collaboration. And the great irony I find in this AI era is we have this amazing ability to basically interact with machines.

6:43 And us humans are the robotic ones. We aren't capable of actually bringing our humanity to the interaction. And so this, to me, it's so important to realize that AI's gonna give you the average of the internet, except if you bring your own expertise, knowledge, wisdom, discernment, taste to the conversation. And as we just discussed, the value of bad ideas, as a creativity expert, I happen to know that in that moment, if I want a good idea, what do I need, Matt? I need a lot of ideas, and I need permission to have bad ideas. And so when I came to the front of the house, I just said to my AI, "I need 20 terrible ways to respond to this situation."

7:25 And it started advocating for certain torture tactics and involving the authorities. It mentioned expelling her from school, which is funny because we homeschool, as you know. And what's funny is actually the amazing thing about the human brain is you go, "Ah, that's a bad idea," but it's kind of interesting. But when the AI said, "You could expel her from school," I go, "School? Oh. Wait, what if we give her the assignment that her job today is to prepare a lesson for her sisters in the schoolroom about why our household rules matter?" She's uniquely qualified to deliver that lesson. And as a consequence for slamming the door in her sister's face and shattering the window, her consequence was she had to teach a lesson to her sisters about why our rules matter.

8:10 Far more inventive and effective as a technique for helping our girls be productive and effective and harmonious members of the home than take away the Kindle Fire for three days. Love it. Love it. Thank you. Your story about the broken glass is not only really helpful to understand the idea of how AI can help us and help us by giving us ideas that we would never implement, but get us thinking more creatively. In your book, The Human Advantage, you talk a lot about unassisted living and handcrafted artisanal work.

8:51 Share more about what that means. Right now, most of us, even though we have access to kind of call it Jetstones age technology, we're still living with Flintstones age habits. So very simply, we have the cognitive equivalent now of what Winston Churchill had a generation ago, right? Everybody knows that one of the things that made Winston Churchill's speeches great was the fact that he had an exceptional secretary or assistant who knew his voice and his audience and his objectives and what he'd said in the last speech and what Neville Chamberlain was saying, right? But most people don't have that. We don't come from means. We don't have the ability to have that kind of cognitive uplift, right?

9:33 And technology is always democratizing what's been available to the elites. But the problem is we have grown accustomed to unassisted living. Assistance is available to us, but we have habitually learned to not only lean on our own abilities, but also to value doing it all ourselves. That's why I joke about handmade artisanal labor. And for whatever reason, we think that our particular work product, there's some virtue in it being handmade artisanal, right? If I'm a financial analyst, I go, "This is handmade artisanal financial analysis." If I'm a marketer, I think there's some value to handmade artisanal marketing copy. And this is patently absurd the moment you think about what's possible.

10:15 You would never go to a cardiologist who practices handcrafted artisanal cardiology. But why? Because you want the best medical process. You want the best healthcare. And the doctor who prides herself that she puts her ear on your chest, you go, "What are you doing, doctor?" She says, "Oh, we practice only handcrafted artisanal cardiology here." You go, "I need a real doctor." Because for a lot of professionals today, they don't see there's now, call it a new standard of care available to them. And to me, that's unassisted living, is the best I can do on my own, is unassisted living. Whereas people who have learned to avail themselves of assistance, who have learned, as I said, to reflexively invite AI in, that's Tobi Lütke's phrase, not mine, but those people are becoming more AI native.

11:03 And rather than it being a last resort, it's the first phone call they make. Got it. So it's attitude and approach that matters. It's taking advantage of what you've got. Yeah. And the thing is, why don't we do it? I mean, there's beliefs below it, right? I mean, if you hand your boss the latest report or piece of analysis or whatever you ought to do, and your boss asks you, "Did AI help with this?" It's almost like an accusation. And what we should do is say, "Absolutely, I availed myself of every possible means of delivering the best possible work." But we don't, and that belies this belief that the thing that I do on my own is more valuable, and that's simply not true. We hesitate to delegate.

11:43 We have a resistance to assistance, and that actually prevents us from getting the kind of boost that's now available. So you've become poetic. Hesitate to delegate. I like it. I think the core belief issue is that people are simply outsourcing the work to AI rather than doing what you're advocating for. You're not saying outsource it, you are saying intensely engage with it. And I think the stereotype that we carry in our head is that if you leverage AI, you're just letting it do the work, and that's not what you're saying at all. I'm not advocating superficial random acts of AI. I'm advocating proficient fluency. Very few of us are thinking, "I have at my disposal a highly capable teammate who's going to thrive under exceptional leadership."

12:29 Okay, I want to get really practical and tactical. You talk about reverse prompting, where you ask AI to interrogate your assumptions and identify the missing information. So one of the ways we can get more value out of AI and our relationship with it is to do something like that. Break it down for us. Simple. Add a single sentence to any prompt. Before you perform this task, please ask me three questions to ensure you have all the context you need so that you can do a great job. Excellent. So you're asking the tool to help you give it the information it needs to help you. Yeah. And we realize this when we're working with people, right? I mean, you and I both, we have longtime partners.

13:11 What percentage of the time does your partner perfectly understand what you say? I mean, if you're humble, you say it's maybe 10%, right? Why in the world would we think that machines are any different? We give an AI a crappy prompt, and we assume it's dumb. It is not a technology problem. It's a management problem, and it's incumbent upon us to be good managers, good leaders. If AI is a thought partner, we got to be the thought leader. And so what you have to do is you can employ all of the techniques you have learned, especially the more experience you have, the better, as a manager, as a coach, as a teacher, as a mentor. And everything you've learned about getting exceptional work product out of this weird intelligence called humans is relevant to AI.

13:53 And all the tips and tricks and things that you do to get great work out of people, you can now get out of AI, provided you bring those same tricks. And one of the most basic ones is what we just talked about, which is with a human, what do you always say? My door's always open. If anything is unclear, feel free to ask me any questions, right? But I would challenge every listener to the show, when's the last time you gave AI permission to ask you questions if anything was unclear? Most people go, "Oh, I didn't know it could ask me questions." That's why you're getting mediocre, suboptimal output because you assume you're perfectly clear in your prompt. And we don't assume that with humans. Why would we assume it with AI? Excellent. I think that analogy is so powerful to help us really think through how we have to work with the AI and have it help us work with it.

14:40 You also suggest working effectively with AI as fundamentally a communication skill. Unpack that for us and help us understand how we can better communicate with AI. The ability to bring good management to the table is kind of the ballgame. Most people will take an AI output and they will refine it themselves, and that leads to underperformance. And it's not much of a lift, right? Because you get something that's eighty percent of the way there. You still got to do a lot of work. Exceptional collaborators to AI say, "Instead of refining output, let me refine the input here. What kind of context do I need to give to help the AI do a better job next time?" And very simply, giving yourself that challenge almost always leads to better results.

15:23 And here's where this is rooted in the research. There's a concept called theory of mind. Are you familiar with that? Yes, absolutely. It's your awareness of what you're doing and how you think about things yourself. Yeah. Specifically, what the other person is thinking. Someone who has a well-developed theory of mind is thinking about, "How is this person perceiving me?" Or, "What are they thinking? What are they wondering?" And it turns out, this is very cool and very unexpected, folks who have a well-developed theory of mind do better with AI than folks who don't, adjusted for all other variables, okay? To say nothing about their ability to collaborate even with other people. But why would that be? Because you're thinking, "What is this other intelligence thinking?" And you could say it's a proxy for empathy.

16:05 It's not exactly the same thing, but the people who go, "Why would it have responded that way?" That is a profoundly communication-centric way of thinking and understanding what was it about what I said that made the AI go in that direction. And so, for example, my dad is an attorney, and sometimes he'll send me a text message saying, "Hey, can Claude do XYZ?" And one day, he's got, like, all of these jury testimonies or depositions, and he's got them in a CSV file, and he needs to convert it to some other format, and he said, "Hey, can, you know, can Claude do this?" So I go to Claude, "Hey, can you please convert this?" Instantaneously, Claude's like, "Here you go. Download the file here." But then I thought, "You know what? I should open this file," right? Open it. It's like a single line with like a thousand columns.

16:47 But here's the thing. What do I do there? What you do when AI disappoints you is hugely important. I said, "Hang on. What about the way I communicated with this AI led it to do that? And how might I change how I communicate? And what are the words I'm using?" But I went back to the AI and I used a simple trick called chain-of-thought prompting, which basically, tell me how you'll think about this problem before you solve it, right? This is well known in cognitive science to help humans make better decisions. So I literally went back into the same chat with Claude. I edited my prompt and I said, "Hey, before you make this file conversion, tell me how you think about problems like this." And then instead of saying, "I've done it," it answers my question, which is now not do the thing, but explain how you do the thing before you do it.

17:33 And so to comply with my request, Claude says, "I would look and see what kind of file type this is. I would make sure that I have the conversion tool required to do that. I would look for these kinds of headings. I would then execute with this rubric. Here's your file." And I opened it, and it's a three hundred line CSV with all of the data in it. And all I did was use a communication tactic called tell me how you think about this before you do it. What I love about this, Jeremy, is it really does highlight effective communication skills and how they can be applied to AI. Thinking to yourself, in this moment, this communication, what can I say that will help our future interactions be better, is a tremendously powerful tool for when we communicate.

18:18 This idea of theory of mind, where you're thinking about how would this person think of this, incredibly valuable. In fact, it's the most frequently cited advice that comes from this show. And the other thing that you said that fits right in is think about how does that person tend to process information and ask them, you know, how do you do it? Well, Jeremy, I knew this would be a fantastic conversation 'cause they always are. I want to end like we always do. I got three questions. One I'm gonna make up just for you. Two you've answered before, but I'll see if they've changed over time. You ready for that? Yeah. Go ahead. So every chapter in The Human Advantage, your new book, ends with a try this now, and I love that. My book does try this now as well. But you end with a try this now prompt to make the next step less intimidating.

19:01 If you could give our audience one immediate, surprisingly fun prompt or exercise to try to write with AI that might fundamentally change how they view it, what would it be? So one of my favorite ones, and I just put this in the newsletter, so it's top of my mind, is consult with three characters: an alien, a toddler, and a retired sea captain. And you basically tell the AI, "For whatever you're doing, I'd like for you to embody three distinct roles: an alien, a toddler, and a sea captain. Would you please consider my request from each of those perspectives and stay in character to deliver your assessment, output, analysis, et cetera?" Almost always, it will unlock a perspective or an angle that is profound, and it just perfectly illustrates how much words matter.

19:47 Because all of these techniques with language models are based on things we know about humans and the small language model on our heads, right? So when you invoke certain personas, it's called the attention mechanism of the model, but it's very similar to our own neural networks, which is it influences the kind of information that gets brought to bear on the problem, and it's incredibly valuable, and the word that got me to say that was fun. It's incredibly fun. I love the toddler. I think that's fantastic. Question number two: Who's a communicator that you admire and why? A communicator I admire, Nate Bargatze. I admire him because his comedy is clean, and it's an incredibly difficult thing to do to be funny without resorting to crass or sexual or racist kinds of commentary.

20:40 And I also, I love the process by which he has arrived at his now, you know, kind of lovely destination, which is he had to opt out of a lot of the conventional pathways. He knew, based on his values and what the kind of work that he wanted to put in the world, he could not accept all offers. There were things he refused to yes and. And to me, it's an incredibly principled stand. It made it way harder for himself, but I think the proof is in the pudding, and his craft and his success are a testament to the value of choosing the road less traveled. I really like his work, and I see exactly what you're saying and the way he had to get there Final question.

21:24 What are the first three ingredients that go into a successful communication recipe? Successful communication. I think care. I think being loose, I would say. I've never communicated in a way that I'm proud of when I'm really uptight. That's just my own experience. I think you do a great job of cultivating an environment where people can be loose here on this show. And then the third, I mean, obviously listening. What you're saying is probably less than half of the communication. We have two ears and one mouth for a reason, right? And I think it kind of highlights some of what we discussed today about considering the audience. And you learn a lot about what's landing or resonating when you shut your mouth and open your ears.

22:04 Care, looseness, and listening. And I really do like the loose idea. You have to be in the moment, able to be agile. When you're tense and locked into something, it gets in the way. And thank you for the compliment. I do try to make this a place where people feel comfortable. Jeremy, tons of valuable information, tons of passion. We all need to be pushing ourselves to be more creative in our work and leveraging AI as a teammate to help us do that. Thank you so much for your revisiting us, and best of luck on your book, The Human Advantage. Thanks, my friend. Appreciate you having me. Thank you for joining us for another episode of Think Fast, Talk Smart, The Podcast. It was awesome to talk once again with Jeremy.

22:45 One of the big takeaways I had is that getting more proficient and better at using AI is just like getting better and more proficient in our communication. It's about thinking about the other person, in this case, the AI. It's about thinking about how would you like the next interactions to go. That empathy, that thinking about the other perspective really makes a difference. To hear more from Jeremy, listen to episode 134, where he's joined by his research colleague, Kian Gohar. This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, Alex McCarthy, and me, Matt Abrahams. Our music is from Floyd Wonder. Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts. Be sure to subscribe and rate us.

23:25 Also, check out our enhanced English language learning content for those of you interested in learning more about English. We have ELL content for each and every episode. Go to ell.fastersmarter.io.